Fifty accounts drove half the engagement in the online fight over meat and dairy
Across 14 months of online debate about meat, dairy and their alternatives, nearly a million posts carried misinformation. Most of them attacked the alternatives, and a very small group of accounts gave them their reach.
The problem
Livestock farming is one of the largest sources of methane, and plant-based and cultivated alternatives to meat and dairy had become a target online. The Changing Markets Foundation wanted to know how much of the conversation about meat, dairy and their alternatives was misinformation, what stories it told, and who was giving those stories their reach. Without that picture, campaigners and policymakers were responding to individual viral posts, with no view of the pattern behind them.
What we did
The Changing Markets Foundation commissioned Ripple Research to run a social listening analysis of the debate. We scanned more than 285 million posts published between 1 June 2022 and 31 July 2023, mostly on X, with Reddit, blogs and web forums alongside. Natural language processing and machine learning did the first pass, and a team of data specialists reviewed the results. That process identified around 948,000 posts carrying misinformation, from 425,226 accounts. We then classified the narratives, traced the peaks in volume back to their triggers, and identified the accounts that carried the most engagement.
What we found
Most of the misinformation attacked the alternatives, and far less of it promoted meat and dairy.
Of the 948,000 posts, 78% disparaged plant-based and cultivated products or the people behind them. The remaining 22% enhanced the image of meat and dairy, mostly through health claims and, to a smaller degree, environmental ones. The debate was being fought on the opponent's ground.
Of the posts promoting meat and dairy, 84% made health claims and 16% made environmental ones.
Running down the competition took up far more of the conversation than making the case for meat.
The attacks came from five directions, and conspiracy was the largest.
The biggest single group of posts, 37% of the total, framed dietary change as an elite plot, with the Great Reset and Bill Gates as recurring characters. A further 24% claimed that alternative proteins were unhealthy or over-processed. Culture-war attacks on the people who eat them, attempts to discredit the climate case, and attacks on the science made up the rest.
Together these five lines of attack account for 78% of the misinformation. The other 22% promoted meat and dairy through health and environmental claims.
The largest share of the argument against alternative proteins had little to do with food.
“Frankenfood”, “soyboys”, “eat bugs”, #meatheals
The vocabulary shows the range: fear of the product, contempt for the people who eat it, a plot behind it, and meat presented as medicine.
A handful of accounts carried the conversation.
Of the 425,226 accounts posting misinformation, around 50,000 attracted all 3.6 million likes, shares and comments. Half of that engagement went to just 50 accounts. Many of those 50 were self-described wellness experts, and others were prominent right-wing and far-right media and political figures. Few of them had any background in food or farming.
Roughly one account in every 8,500 captured half of the attention. The last bar is drawn at its minimum visible width; to scale it would be invisible.
A conversation this concentrated can be mapped, account by account.
A single preprint showed how fast a convenient claim can travel.
One of the sharpest peaks in volume followed a preprint from the University of California, Davis, which suggested that lab-grown meat could be 25 times worse for the climate than beef. The study had not been peer reviewed, yet it was shared as settled science and used in arguments over agricultural policy in Ireland and beyond. Other peaks followed Great Reset conspiracy content and posts from climate denialists.
The debate looked like a mass movement. Half of its engagement came from fifty accounts, and few of them were talking about food.
What it led to
The Changing Markets Foundation published the findings as "Truth, Lies and Culture Wars" in November 2023, on the eve of COP28. The report concluded that, while the meat and dairy industry may not be driving the most extreme misinformation, it benefits from the "business as usual" that the noise protects. It called on governments to reaffirm their commitments to the Global Methane Pledge and to base decisions on evidence and not on polarised online debate.
The study also set the direction for later work. The Dutch farmers' protests, one of its case studies, became a dedicated analysis. Ripple Research and the Changing Markets Foundation went on to study the backlash to the EAT-Lancet report, published in 2025. The Foundation's wider argument about how the industry delays climate action is now set out in a book, "The New Merchants of Doubt" by Nusa Urbancic.

The Foundation's account of how the meat and dairy industry delays, distracts from and derails climate action, developed from its 2024 report of the same name.
About the book →Working on a similar question?
Most engagements start with a conversation about what you're trying to understand and what a useful answer would look like.